Flight Tracker Map > Blog > Aviation news > Aviation safety > Ethiopian ET302 final report released, NTSB and BEA issue comments
Flight Tracker Map > Blog > Aviation news > Aviation safety > Ethiopian ET302 final report released, NTSB and BEA issue comments
- Aviation safety
Share this article
- Updated: January 26, 2023
Just before the end of the year, Ethiopian investigators published their final report on the crash of Ethiopian Airlines flight ET302. Flight 302 crashed shortly after takeoff from Addis Ababa Bole Airport on 10 March 2019. Operated by Boeing 737-8 MAX ET-AVJ, it was the second crash of a 737 MAX in just over four months and led to a worldwide 20 month grounding of the MAX while Boeing and regulators made changes to the aircraft.
Following the publication of the final report, both the US National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) and French Bureau d’Enquêtes et d’Analyses (BEA) took the highly unusual step of publishing separate comments on the report.
Ethiopian investigators’ probable cause: MCAS
In their final report, Ethiopian investigators solely focus on the activation of the Maneuvering Characteristics Augmentation System as the probable cause of the accident.
“Repetitive and uncommanded airplane-nose-down inputs from the MCAS due to erroneous AOA input, and its unrecoverable activation system which made the airplane dive with the rate of -33,000 ft/minclose to the ground was the most probable cause of the accident.”
Section 3.2, ET302 final report
MCAS is the software system Boeing introduced on the 737 MAX to make the aircraft’s behavior in certain phases of flight the same as the previous generation 737NG. This was done to to minimize the training necessary for pilots moving between the two generations of aircraft. When activated at high angles of attack, MCAS pushes the nose of the aircraft downward.
At the time of the accident, MCAS was activated based on data from a single angle of attack sensor, which in the case of ET302 was damaged and providing erroneous data. This caused the aircraft to believe its AOA was much higher than it actually was.
The Ethiopian investigators further list a series of contributing factors to the accident that focus on the design of MCAS, the design and certification of the 737 MAX generally, and Boeing’s training and operational materials. The report does not address any issues related to human factors or crew actions.
ET302 accident investigation report process
In most accident investigations, the final report is a product of the collaborative effort of all agencies that are party to the investigation speaking in a singular voice. To this end, the state conducting the investigation sends a copy of the final report to all parties before publication, inviting their “significant and substantial comments” [ICAO Annex 13, Chapter 6.3] on the draft report.
Any comments received within 60 days are to either be incorporated into the draft report or, “if desired by the State that provided comments, append the comments to the Final Report.” [ICAO Annex 13, Chapter 6.3] In the case of the Ethiopian ET302 final report, the Ethiopian Aircraft Accident Investigation Bureau neither incorporated the comments of the US NTSB and French BEA nor did it append their full comments to the final report as requested. The electronic version of the Ethiopian final report includes only links to the “earlier and now outdated version of the NTSB’s comments” and according to the BEA, “the EAIB report contains a link to a BEA document which does not contain the comments that the BEA had finally requested to be appended [to the final report].”
NTSB and BEA release their comments
Given this unusual situation, both the NTSB and BEA separately released the full comments each agency wished to see appended to the final report. Both the NTSB and BEA agree with the EAIB regarding MCAS’ contribution to the accident and both agencies’ comments relate to the human factors and crew actions that are not discussed in the EAIB report.
“The BEA shares the analysis and conclusions of the EAIB report regarding the contribution of the MCAS system of the 737 Max to the accident. BEA's comments are mainly related to the analysis of the crew's performance and its contribution to the accident scenario, in particular during the first part of the flight (between the rupture of the angle of attack vane and the activation of the MCAS system). The BEA considers that this analysis would make it possible to draw safety lessons beyond those related to the MCAS system.”
BEA press release accompanying comments on the ET302 final report
For its part, the NTSB also says the “final report included significant changes from the last draft the EAIB provided the NTSB” and it is in the process of reviewing those changes to see if further comment is necessary.
Read the NTSB’s comments
More to the probable cause than just MCAS
The NTSB and BEA’s comments both focus on the additional contribution the crew’s actions had on the accident, areas on which the EAIB spends little to no time in the final report. The NTSB comments propose two additional factors be added to the probable cause:
- the operator’s failure to ensure that its flight crews were prepared to properly respond to uncommanded stabilizer trim movement in the manner outlined in Boeing’s flight crew operating manual (FCOM) bulletin and the FAA’s emergency airworthiness directive (AD) (both issued 4 months before the accident) and
- the airplane’s impact with a foreign object, which damaged the AOA sensor and caused the erroneous AOA
The BEA focuses most closely on the crew’s actions during the period of time after the AOA vane was damaged, but before the first activation of MCAS. Regarding the accident’s probable cause, the French agency says it “believes that the crew’s inadequate actions and the insufficient co*ckpit Resource Management (CRM) played a role in the chain of events that led to the accident, in particular during the first phase of the flight, before the first MCAS activation.”
NTSB releases additional comments
The NTSB released a second set of comments regarding the Ethiopian investigators’ final report on 24 January 2023. The NTSB says that the final report released to the public included substantive changes made after the NTSB reviewed the report, in contravention to ICAO annex 13 stipulations. The NTSB says further that the report includes findings that are “unsupported by evidence — for example, that aircraft electrical problems caused erroneous angle-of-attack (AOA) output.”
Ethiopian 302 ADS-B Data
See the ADS-B data received by Flightradar24 from Ethiopian 302 and our discussion of the data from the time of the crash.
See Flightradar24 ADS-B data from ET302
737 MAXET302Ethiopian Airlines
- Published:January 6, 2023
Get the latest aviation news delivered to you
Get the latest aviation news delivered to you
Flight tracking and aviation industry news direct to your inbox
Aviation news comes quickly, so join more than 600,000 others who receive weekly aviation industry and flight tracking news from Flightradar24 direct to their inbox.
- The best aviation photos
- Bite-sized aviation news
- Exclusive flight tracking data
Share this article
Ian Petchenik’s love of aviation began at an early age growing up next to Chicago’s O’Hare Airport. As Flightradar24’s director of communications and co-host of the AvTalk podcast Ian now gets to share that passion for aviation with millions of Flightradar24 users and listeners around the world.
More about Ian Petchenik
Ian Petchenik’s love of aviation began at an early age growing up next to Chicago’s O’Hare Airport. As Flightradar24’s director of communications and co-host of the AvTalk podcast Ian now gets to share that passion for aviation with millions of Flightradar24 users and listeners around the world.
More about Ian Petchenik
Latest video
Trending articles
SODPROPS: aviation’s best acronym?
Virgin comes back to Canada with Toronto flights
Tower warns Southwest of low altitude on approach
Expanding flight tracking with UAT coverage—and how you can help!
Learn more | Try free for 7 days
See all subscription plans
Get weekly updates on Flightradar24 and have the latest aviation news land in your inbox.
- The best aviation photos
- Bite-sized aviation news
- Exclusive flight tracking data
AvTalk Episode 273: Congress, Dutch roll, and bad titanium
Listen now
How flight tracking works
Flightradar24 combines data from several data sources including ADS-B, MLAT and radar data.
Find out more >>
Search the blog
Follow us
Latest AvTalk Podcasts
AvTalk Episode 272: Reduced separation
AvTalk Episode 271: Boeing’s plan to fix itself
AvTalk Episode 270: Coming to an airplane near you, news from AIX 2024
AvTalk Episode 269: Extreme turbulence
Is Clear Air Turbulence becoming more common?
In recent years there has been a noticeable uptick in
VietJet begins Hanoi-Sydney flights
VietJet inaugurated its regular operations between Hanoi and Sydney on
What actually causes turbulence?
Turbulence is a common yet complex weather phenomenon that affects
Southwest flight makes “excessive descent” during go around in Hawaii
A Southwest Airlines flight from Honolulu to Lihue made an
More stories
- Aviation safety
A Southwest Airlines flight from Honolulu to Lihue made an “excessive descent” during a go around at Lihue, flying as low as 400 feet…
- Airline routes
After a four-year suspension due to the pandemic, Hainan Airlines resumed its services to Vienna in the Austrian capital. The first flight arrived on…
- Airline routes
Las Vegas, Aer Lingus’ new destination in the United States. The Sports and Entertainment Capital of the World gains a new connection to…
- Airline news
Lufthansa (LH/DLH), Germany’s largest airline and one of the most prominent in Europe, has a rich history dating back to its founding in 1953….
Explore the top 10 most tracked aircraft and find out why these particular aircraft draw so much interest.
Track the aircraft types ✈
Help to grow our flight tracking coverage
We are continually looking to improve our flight tracking and the airports below are where new receivers will add the most coverage. Apply for a receiver today and if accepted you’ll receiver a free Flightradar24 Business Subscription.
Apply for a free receiver
Latest videos
Meet the custom A330 for MILITARY (mid-air refueling and more!)
Gdańsk Airport Grand Tour: ATC, Marshaling, VIP terminal, FBOs, Hangars and more!
Up close with the STRANGEST Airbus
Flying to the South African bush with Fed Air (Grand Caravan adventure)
More stories
SODPROPS: aviation’s best acronym?
Virgin comes back to Canada with Toronto flights
Tower warns Southwest of low altitude on approach
Expanding flight tracking with UAT coverage—and how you can help!
Aviation news
A deep dive into Wizz Air
Air France inaugurates flights to Phoenix
Aurora Borealis and Saudi Arabia’s commercial center: BA announces two new routes
Emirates announces first A350 routes
Try the full Flightradar24 experience free for 7 days
Remove ads and unlock over 50 additional features
Learn more | Try free for 7 days
See all subscription plans